I love this shoes! They're extremely comfortable. They are leather lined which helps me a great deal because I always get blisters when not using socks but not with these. Also in the back of the heel the leather is cut in a U shape to avoid rubbing in the back of the heel. Those smart features of design are what convinced me to keep them despite the price. However, I gave it 4 stars because of the rubber stitched heel. The shoe is very pretty on top but that heel makes it look very informal. If it had a black or any less obvious casual heel it would have been perfect to wear with a dress because the top is very pretty. but like this they're only good for jeans on the weekend. It's a shame, they're almost perfect.